Bitcoin’s summer-bottom case rests on a combination of price recovery and on-chain signals—not a single indicator proving the bear market is over. CryptoQuant CEO Ki Young Ju says the downturn ended during the summer; Benjamin Cowen has become less confident in his earlier call for a later low, while still flagging incomplete bottoming signals. Dan Gambardello’s skepticism about the four-year halving timetable offers another reason not to assume a late-year bottom is inevitable.
3
8
17
39
Why the summer low is back in focus
Bitcoin fell to around $57,000 during the early-summer decline. Since June, its monthly closes have moved higher, and it later broke above its May high. Cowen said he had not expected Bitcoin to take out that high this year and that the move shifted the burden of proof toward the bears. It is meaningful price action, but it does not by itself establish that a lasting bull market has begun.
14
17
23
That recovery contrasts with Cowen’s earlier view. In July, he said a fourth-quarter low remained possible; in September, he put a 65% probability on Bitcoin making a lower low and pointed to realized price near $53,000 as a level to watch. His more recent comments suggest a changed balance of probabilities, not a claim that downside risk has disappeared.
20
27
17
What Ki Young Ju sees in on-chain data
Ju points to rising inflows to accumulation addresses and a higher 30-day average as signs that fresh capital is entering the market. He also says MVRV stayed above 1 during the decline, meaning the measure did not show the same broad holder loss seen in some previous downturns. These signals support his view that the summer marked a transition to a new cycle, but they cannot guarantee that the low will hold.
3
16
There is an important distinction between Ju’s MVRV reading and Cowen’s MVRV Z-Score analysis. Cowen’s July memo said the Z-Score was bouncing but had not reset below zero, and that Bitcoin had approached—but not tested—realized price near $53,000. His report described the evidence as a reason to shift posture, not a definitive bottom signal. The metrics and interpretations are not identical, which helps explain why the analysts can read the same broad market phase differently.
8
16
A different market—and a more restrained price scenario
Ju argues that Bitcoin’s larger market and growing institutional ownership may dampen both its upside and its subsequent declines compared with cycles dominated by retail trading. On that basis, he expects a gain of three to five times from the cycle low rather than another 10×-plus rally.
16
If that multiple is applied to a low near $58,000, the arithmetic implies roughly $174,000 to $290,000. That is an illustration of Ju’s scenario, not a precise price target or deadline; reports on his forecast note that he did not specify either.
6
21
Why Gambardello questions the four-year timetable
The traditional four-year cycle view uses Bitcoin’s halving schedule as a guide to when market peaks and bottoms may occur. Gambardello has moved away from treating that pattern as a dependable calendar, arguing instead that broader economic expansion and contraction—tracked in part through indicators such as the ISM PMI—are more relevant to market turns. In that framework, a summer low can fit even if a halving-based forecast points to later in the year.
39
42
What would challenge or strengthen the case?
A renewed fall below the summer low would undermine the idea that the bottom is in. Cowen’s earlier bearish scenario focused on the area near $53,000, where Bitcoin’s price had approached realized price without testing it. Conversely, holding the recovery and eventually reclaiming the previous high near $126,000 would provide stronger evidence of a sustained new cycle than clearing May’s high alone. Neither outcome is guaranteed by the current signals.
8
27
6
The evidence therefore supports a plausible summer-bottom thesis, not a settled verdict. Rising closes and Ju’s accumulation signals lean bullish; Cowen’s concerns about an incomplete reset keep the alternative scenario alive. The next test is whether Bitcoin can sustain its recovery without revisiting the lows.