Gilbert also said he will restart the development blog he ran during the first game's production, promising regular updates for fans .
The original Thimbleweed Park raised $626,250 on Kickstarter in 2014, well above its $375,000 goal . But Gilbert has explicitly ruled out crowdfunding for the sequel. In a December 2025 interview with Ars Technica, he called Kickstarter "basically dead these days as a way of funding games," arguing it has shifted from a development-capital source into more of a marketing tool
. He elaborated that the original game cost roughly $1.1 million to make — $600,000 from Kickstarter and $500,000 from private investors he found later — and that even that full amount could not be raised on the platform today
.
Instead, Thimbleweed Park 2 is being self-published by Gilbert's studio Terrible Toybox with backing from a single private investor. Gilbert has not named the investor or disclosed the amount .
This funding path was not Gilbert's first choice. In late 2025, he canceled an ambitious top-down RPG project described as a blend of classic Zelda, Diablo, and Thimbleweed Park after failing to secure publisher or investor support . Speaking to Ars Technica, Gilbert said he worked with a team of just three people — including an artist and a designer — for about a year before realizing it was not going to happen. "I simply didn't have the financial resources or time to create a vast open-world game like that," he stated
. He described the current publishing landscape as one where "publishers are fixated on analytics" and unwilling to back original mid-tier games, adding that the publisher deals he was offered were "horrible"
.
According to the official description, the new murder takes place at the Edmund Mansion, with Agents Ray and Reyes returning as lead investigators — though the description playfully adds "or are they?" . The game is described as "more Thimbleweed Park than ever" and will retain the pixel-art visual style and classic point-and-click format of the original
. Console versions have not been confirmed at this early stage, though the original game did eventually release on Xbox, PlayStation, Switch, iOS, and Android
.
Fans eager to follow development can wishlist Thimbleweed Park 2 on Steam now, with the GOG version confirmed alongside it .