Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella’s warning at The New York Times DealBook Summit was about who captures value online as people hand more browsing and shopping tasks to AI agents. He likened the possible shift to the move from web portals such as Yahoo to search engines such as Google: a new intermediary can change how people find businesses, and how money flows between them.
9
Amazon’s dispute with Meta’s Muse offers a concrete example of the tension. A retailer may want to control access to its store, but if an agent directs a shopper elsewhere, that retailer could lose visibility in the agent’s results.
From the “human web” to an agentic web
Nadella described an internet increasingly shaped by agents rather than direct human visits. In his account, companies built around advertising and “human web” traffic could be reshuffled as agents change how people discover and interact with services.
9
The Yahoo-to-Google analogy is about a change in the gatekeeper. Portals once organized access to the web; search engines later became a major way people found information. Nadella’s comparison suggests that AI agents could become another layer between customers and businesses, changing which companies control discovery and which get paid for traffic or transactions.
9
That could also change online monetization. Coverage of Nadella’s remarks described a possible move from selling attention toward cost-per-click or transaction-based arrangements.
12
14 That is a forecast about where business models may evolve, not a claim that advertising will simply vanish.
Amazon’s Muse standoff shows the retailer’s dilemma
Amazon blocked Meta’s Muse from accessing its store in September. Reporting described Amazon’s concerns about permission and whether the agent identified itself; those accounts do not establish every detail of the dispute.
2
35
The consequences for discovery are visible in Muse’s shopping instructions: it now points users toward Walmart, Target, and Best Buy, and leaves Amazon out unless a user specifically asks for it.
33 That does not show how many purchases Amazon has lost. It does illustrate the competitive risk: a store excluded from an agent’s default search may be less likely to be considered during that shopping journey.
The alternative is not necessarily unrestricted access. Amazon launched a text-based way for customers to shop with its own Alexa agent, keeping the shopping interaction within Amazon’s service.
34 And CEO Andy Jassy said Amazon had not ruled out admitting outside shopping agents, while stressing that the experience must work for customers and provide a “fair exchange of value.”
37
44
The choice is about control—and access
For retailers, blocking third-party agents can help preserve control over the customer relationship and shopping experience. But as agents become a route to product discovery, refusing access may also mean not appearing in an agent’s recommendations. Muse’s changed instructions show how that exclusion can play out; they do not, on their own, prove that shoppers will follow the agent or complete purchases elsewhere.
33
Nadella’s central point is that the web’s economic model could change when software, rather than people, does more of the browsing. The exact pace and commercial outcome remain uncertain. The immediate question for retailers is practical: how can they protect their data and customer experience while ensuring they remain reachable when customers use an agent to shop?