Key review excerpts:
| Outlet | Score | Key takeaway |
|---|---|---|
| Creative Bloq | 8/10 | "Sacrificing some intimacy that made VR originals unforgettable, but preserves everything else that matters" |
| Console Creatures | 9/10 | "Does a great job bringing two wonderful adventures to more players… puzzles and action that are always rewarding" |
| SmashPad | 4.5/5 | "If you are looking for an interesting story, unique puzzle mechanics, and enjoyable exploration, it's hard to beat" |
| SECTOR.sk | 7.5/10 | "Lost something in transition to flat screens but also gained something… charming fairy tale" |
| WayTooManyGames | 8.5/10 | "A really great collection… has heart, whimsy, partnership, and joy" |
| TechRaptor | 7/10 | "Fantastic fantasy adventure… first half drags a bit, but picks up" |
| NintendoWorldReport | 7.5/10 | "Clear areas where this misses the mark… but Switch 2 makes a great window into Quill's adventure" |
| Hey Poor Player | 3.5/5 | Praised the price but noted some VR-to-flat-screen friction |
| TheXboxHub | Unscored | "About as rich as an adventure game can get… enthralling and elegantly constructed" |
Critics consistently note that the transition from VR to traditional displays is the central challenge and the most interesting design question:
Polyarc approached Moss: The Forgotten Relic as a "ground-up reimagining" rather than a simple port . The game rebuilds the core interactions for a standard controller:
The result, according to most critics, is a game that captures the charm and puzzle design of the originals even if the sense of physical presence is diminished. Console Creatures summed it up: "This is an action puzzle game that many, many more people should check out now that it's more widely accessible" .
The game arrives during a relatively quiet July window, launching the same day as D-topia (Strong, 76 on OpenCritic) and a week before Splatoon Raiders and Halo: Campaign Evolved, giving it a clear path to attention from puzzle-platformer and action-adventure fans .
Moss: The Forgotten Relic is a well-received, affordably priced collection that successfully reimagines a VR franchise for flat screens. Despite some minor friction from the transition — largely the loss of VR's physical intimacy and some control quirks — nearly all critics agree Quill's charm, the inventive puzzles, and the gorgeous world-building shine through. At $19.99 for two full games and DLC, it's an easy recommendation for anyone who missed the VR originals .