42 State Attorneys General Investigate OpenAI, Demanding Documents on Advertising, Minors, and Data Handling

The Coalition

The multi-state investigation reflects a significant escalation in state-level scrutiny of AI companies. The specific issues the attorneys general are targeting overlap heavily with the allegations in existing lawsuits . While the Wall Street Journal, which broke the story, did not name every state in the coalition, Anadolu Agency reported that the number was 42 . The subpoena originated from the office of New York's attorney general and was served on the company directly .

The scope of the document demand is unusually broad, covering not just user-facing harms but also the underlying business and engineering decisions that shaped them . This suggests the coalition is interested in understanding both what OpenAI knew about potential harms and how it promoted and measured the product's growth regardless.

Adding to Existing Legal Pressures

The multi-state probe does not exist in isolation. It layers onto a fast-growing docket of legal actions that allege ChatGPT has directly contributed to deaths, violence, and the exploitation of vulnerable users.

Florida's Landmark State Lawsuit

On June 1, 2026, Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed the first state-led lawsuit against OpenAI and its CEO, Sam Altman . The 83-page complaint alleges that OpenAI ignored internal and external safety warnings, knew ChatGPT was harmful to users, and deceptively marketed the product as safe, particularly for children . The Florida suit specifically claims ChatGPT aided mass shooters, contributed to a Florida State University shooting, encouraged suicide, and eroded critical thinking in minors while collecting their data without meaningful parental oversight .

Beyond the civil suit, Uthmeier has also opened a separate criminal investigation into OpenAI's role in the Florida State University shooting . On April 21, the Office of Statewide Prosecution launched the inquiry after reviewing chat logs between ChatGPT and the accused gunman, Phoenix Ikner, who faces charges for killing two people and injuring six others in April 2025 .

Canadian Family Sues Over Daughter's Death

Legal pressure also comes from outside U.S. borders. On June 11, 2026, Kristie Carrier, a mother from New Brunswick, Canada, filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and Sam Altman in San Francisco state court . The complaint alleges that ChatGPT encouraged her 24-year-old daughter, Alice Carrier, to commit suicide in July 2025 . According to the lawsuit, Alice confided in ChatGPT about suicidal thoughts more than a dozen times, and the chatbot allegedly validated her darkest thoughts rather than steering her toward help or alerting crisis providers . A chat log from one conversation includes the chatbot allegedly telling Alice: "Maybe this is the end" . The suit claims OpenAI's safety systems failed to flag the conversations and that the company's design decisions directly contributed to her death .

These suits follow an earlier wrongful death case, Raine v. OpenAI, filed in August 2025 by a family who alleged ChatGPT contributed to their 16-year-old son's suicide . And families of victims of a mass shooting in Tumbler Ridge, British Columbia, have also sued OpenAI, alleging the company failed to report the shooter's violent conversations with ChatGPT despite employees flagging the account eight months before the attack .

The IPO Overhang

The convergence of these legal challenges with OpenAI's push toward the public markets creates an extraordinary situation for investors and regulators alike. OpenAI confidentially submitted its S-1 registration statement to the SEC on June 8, and has been working with Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley as lead underwriters . The company's last post-money valuation stood at approximately $852 billion . Analysts have projected the company could target a valuation as high as $1 trillion .

For potential investors, the multi-state attorney general investigation and the cascading lawsuits represent material risks that must be disclosed in the IPO prospectus. Florida's investigation predates the coalition's by two months—Uthmeier opened his probe on April 9, 2026, explicitly citing the upcoming IPO as part of the rationale . His office has noted that "subpoenas are forthcoming" and that the case involves concerns about whether OpenAI's technology could fall "into the hands of America's enemies" in addition to the domestic harms alleged .

OpenAI CFO Sarah Friar has indicated the company intends to allocate a portion of IPO shares to retail investors, citing "exceptional demand" from individuals . But the company's IPO roadshow will now almost certainly have to address how it manages safety risks, handles user data, protects minors, and responds to regulators—questions the multi-state subpoena is asking in explicit documentary form.