Apple’s leadership handoff began with a strong market response. John Ternus became CEO on September 1, 2026, while Tim Cook moved to executive chairman.
16 By late September, Apple shares had reached a $345.34 intraday record high; measured against the reported $316.85 transition-day close, that is a gain of roughly 9%.
The rally also pushed Apple back to the $5 trillion threshold. Reports on September 22 put the closing price at a record $344.70 and market capitalization just above $5 trillion, alongside a roughly 34% trailing-12-month share-price gain.
20 That is an impressive opening for a new CEO, but it also sets a high bar for the company’s next operating results.
The September launch gave investors a concrete catalyst
Ternus’s first major product event on September 9 introduced the iPhone 18 Pro and Pro Max, as well as Apple’s first foldable handset, the iPhone Duo.
2
11 The Duo starts at $1,999, positioning it as a premium addition to the lineup rather than a mass-market volume product.
10
For investors, the significance is less about the management change by itself than the possibility of a stronger premium-device replacement cycle. Higher-priced Pro models and a new form factor can support revenue per device if demand and supply hold up. The launch therefore gave the stock a product-led reason to rally—while making future execution more important.
Early demand signals are positive, but incomplete
Evercore ISI raised its Apple price target to $380 from $365 while maintaining an Outperform rating after surveying nearly 4,000 U.S. consumers. In that survey, 53% of respondents said they planned to buy an iPhone 18 Pro or Pro Max, and 32% planned to buy the Pro Max, up from 29% in the prior-year comparison.
37
46
That is encouraging evidence for premium mix, but it is not the same as reported sales. The foldable’s demand profile is particularly uncertain: Evercore survey data indicated 14% purchase interest in the Duo, while the device’s preorders were not scheduled to begin until October 16.
42
44 Initial interest must still translate into orders, availability, unit shipments and margins.
Why analyst targets remain widely divided
The iPhone launch did not create a uniform Wall Street view. Evercore’s $380 target reflects confidence in a stronger upgrade cycle.
46 TD Cowen maintained a Buy rating and a $400 target, the more optimistic case for the new product lineup.
38 UBS, by contrast, maintained a Hold rating and a $296 target in the available consensus data.
33
Aggregate target-price snapshots also show little obvious consensus upside at then-current prices: one source listed a $340.14 average target, while another listed $328.22.
34
45 The precise average varies with the provider and date, but the broad message is consistent: some analysts see meaningful upside from premium iPhones and the Duo, while others believe much of the good news is already reflected in the share price.
Apple vs. Nvidia: a valuation race with different growth profiles
Apple’s rise has narrowed the gap with Nvidia. On September 22, one market snapshot placed Apple near $4.98 trillion and Nvidia near $5.50 trillion.
18 Apple had also overtaken Nvidia briefly in July, when Reuters reported valuations of about $4.88 trillion for Apple and $4.86 trillion for Nvidia.
17
The companies’ growth drivers are very different. The September comparison cited Nvidia revenue growth above 80% annually, versus roughly 14% for Apple.
18 That does not prevent Apple from taking the market-cap lead—market value reflects expectations, profitability and the price investors will pay for each business—but it explains why the lead may be difficult to sustain without an upside surprise in Apple’s growth or margins.
The next proof point is earnings, not the headline valuation
Apple’s next scheduled fiscal-Q4 earnings date was estimated as October 29, 2026.
24 As of September 23, those results had not occurred, so they cannot yet be used as evidence that the rally is durable.
The company entered the period with solid reported momentum: fiscal third-quarter revenue was $109.4 billion, up 16% year over year, while iPhone revenue rose 22% to $54.3 billion.
24 But Apple’s September-quarter revenue guidance was 9% to 11% growth, and its 47% to 48% gross-margin outlook included an expected benefit from tariff refunds.
25
27
That makes the earnings release the key validation event. Investors will be looking for evidence that iPhone 18 Pro demand is converting into revenue, that the premium mix supports margins, and that management’s December-quarter outlook justifies a valuation near $5 trillion.
Bottom line
Apple’s first three weeks under Ternus were a market success: a roughly 9% run from the transition-day close to the record intraday high, renewed contact with the $5 trillion mark and a high-profile product launch. The momentum has a credible foundation in stronger premium-iPhone demand signals, but the case is not settled.
A durable move higher depends on execution: real iPhone 18 sales, a successful Duo rollout, resilient margins and guidance that exceeds already-elevated expectations. Until those results arrive, Apple’s challenge to Nvidia for the title of most valuable public company remains plausible—but not proven.