Oil prices can rise even as supply recovers when buyers worry that the recovery may not last. Goldman Sachs’ Daan Struyven says refiners were seeking crude while it was available, supported by low inventories, while investors used oil exposure to hedge portfolios against renewed Middle East disruption. Brent settled at $116.72 on October 23, up 3.14% that day and at its highest settlement since April 29.
17
18
45
Why refiners bought crude as flows recovered
Recovering exports do not necessarily mean inventories have been replenished or that future deliveries are secure. Struyven said intensifying shipping attacks and Houthi strikes on infrastructure increased refiners’ concern about supply, while low inventories made restocking more urgent. That combination encouraged physical buyers to secure barrels before another interruption.
17
18
The risks were not all confirmed losses of oil production. Reuters reported that Houthi attacks on Saudi Arabia and a spill reported by UAE authorities heightened concern about further disruption. The Houthis also claimed attacks on Saudi targets including an Aramco facility in Yanbu; the claim itself does not establish that the facility was damaged or that output was lost.
45
51
Why investors used oil as a hedge
The buying was not limited to refiners. The podcast description says investors were also buying oil exposure as a portfolio hedge, amid unusually high sensitivity of bond and equity prices to oil. In that context, oil can serve as protection against the market impact of a supply shock, even when current crude flows have improved.
15
Expectations of possible renewed U.S. strikes on Iran added to market concern, but reports described them as expectations—not confirmed future action. The price response therefore reflected risk about what could happen as well as the barrels already being produced and shipped.
47
The October 23 rally, in context
Brent settled at $116.72 on October 23, a $3.55 increase, or 3.14%, from the previous day. Reuters reported it was the highest settlement since April 29 and that Brent gained 6% over the week. Those figures describe the market move; they do not by themselves show that the reported incidents had already caused an equivalent loss of supply.
45
Why Goldman still forecast lower prices
Goldman Sachs’ forecast assumed that Middle East supply would gradually recover. The bank projected Brent at $90 in December 2026—up from its earlier $85 forecast—and an average of $80 in 2027. Those are forecasts, not guaranteed prices, and depend on the expected supply recovery.
1
16
Struyven’s October analysis said Brent spot prices included a risk premium of nearly $25 per barrel because escalation could curtail supply and draw inventories down further. In other words, the quoted market price included a premium for possible disruption beyond what the bank considered fair value under its supply-and-demand assumptions. If supply recovery continues, that premium could fade; further attacks or infrastructure damage could keep it elevated or add to it.
18
Crude and refined products do not recover at the same pace
A recovery in crude exports does not automatically restore supplies of diesel and other refined products. The International Energy Agency reported that Middle East refined-product and LPG shipments had risen more slowly than crude flows and remained below half their pre-war levels in its October report. That points to a slower product-export recovery, but the available figures do not establish the specific roles of damaged refineries or Ukrainian strikes on Russian diesel production.
57
The main takeaway is that recovering crude flows and rising prices are not contradictory: buyers can respond to today’s tight inventories and the risk of tomorrow’s disruption at the same time. Goldman’s lower price outlook rests on supply recovering; the upside risk comes from events that could interrupt it.
17
18